• Jeannette posted an update: 2 years, 6 months ago

    Noticed that नहीं is a portmanteau, and the ”pure” word for no would be ना. Is this true? Is there a good lesson here where the negative is explored?

    • Acchaa, language origin is mysterious, but as far as I’ve heard, ’na’ is the original Sanskrit word, and ’nahiin’ developed in Hindi, possibly as a combination of ’na’ plus another word. 
      I think by itself, it is like an informal ’No’ (Naw) instead of ’(Ji) Nahiin”. But ’na’ also can be used like ”don’t” or ”neither”; 
      ”Dhobi ka kutta na ghar ka na ghaat ka” The washerman’s dog belongs neither at home nor on the river bank. 

    • Why is it because the dog is dirty? Poor thing would have nowhere to go would it?

      I saw the ”he” part somewhere on its own- in fact this is what made me realize that Nahi was a portmanteau. The context was it meant ”is” but a different kind of is than है. Wishing I had documented this sighting…. but like birdwatching I’m sure to encounter this elusive species again. (it was somewhere around here actually)

    • P.S. ’na’- (&’an’-) can prefix words, to make something be ”un-something”: pasand, napasand, etc.

    • ही is at the end of the 9th ”Glossaries Alive” !

    • Sentences with Nahin or Na. 9example i.e उदाहरण

      1.मैं तुमसे बात नहीं करना चाहता | Main tumesy baat nahin karna chahta. Baat is also called. वार्तालाप Vaartalaap i.e conversation means baatchee

      You can add Huun or without that also it is spoken.

      2 ..न तुम मुझे याद करते और न मैं आता | Na tum mujhe yad kartey aur na main aata. had you not remembered me, I would not havet come.

      3. मेरे न कहने पर भी वह नहीं माना | Mere na kahney par bhee vah nahin maana. Despite my telling NO, he did not listen to.

      4.मुझे खीर नहीं चाहिए | Mujhe kheer nahin chahiye. I do not want sweet pudding.
      Kheer is also called Payas (Payasam in South India).

      Mat मत means also NO. मुझे तंग मत करो Mujhe tang mat karo. Do not pester .
      me.

      Please note मतदान matdaan means casting of votes.
      एकमत means all agree,

      For information Kheer is a wonderful sweet dish( rice or sago or jackfruit,, almond. For this , milk is must+ sugar. In south Jaggery is also used while making payasam.

      tks.

      Regards

      suresh


Powered by WishList Member - Membership Site Software